giles
4e397e599f
Adds a starting-point decision-commit on the coordinator branch
(sx1:9f05cceb...) marking the state where all review infrastructure is in
place — plan, rulings, quick-wins batch (dc7aa709), and the forge itself —
as the baseline from which the fix program starts. Records the sequencing
rule (W14 test-gate first, then W1/K01) so the next agent picks up correctly.
Coordinator branch: spawn -> baseline -> done -> START (4 commits).
forge.sxdata re-dumped (46KB); forge-build.sxsrc stays the reproducible source.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
SX Review — 2026-07-03
Findings from three parallel review sessions of the SX language/runtime, plus the master remediation plan.
| File | What |
|---|---|
| PLAN.md | Master remediation plan: 15 workstreams (W1–W15), execution order, and a full per-finding coverage ledger. Start here. |
| RULINGS.md | 40 draft normative rulings (R1–R40). Phase-0 gate — ratify before the semantics fixes. |
| core.md | Language core / spec semantics lane (K01–K110). |
| hosts.md | Per-host implementations + FFI lane (J*, C*, JS*, P*, S*, PY). |
| conformance.md | Cross-host agreement + test adequacy lane (F1–F15, S1–S5). |
Status: the quick-wins batch (commit dc7aa709) landed 13 fixes + 4 partials; suite at baseline
5762p/274f (fail set byte-identical). Everything else is OPEN/GATE/DEFERRED per PLAN.md's ledger.
Highest-value open items: K01 (guard/handler re-raise hang — DoS-able, server+browser), S1 (live HTTP crash under load), K03 (shift-k double-execution), and W14 (test gate — the enabler that makes all other fixes verifiable).
Blocking decisions (maintainer): D1 host lineup, D2 ratify rulings, D3 gate definition.