# Haskell-on-SX: completeness roadmap (Phases 7–16) Continuation of `plans/haskell-on-sx.md`. Phases 1–6 are complete (156/156 conformance tests, 18 programs, 775 total hk-on-sx tests). This document covers the next ten features toward a more complete Haskell 98 subset. ## Scope decisions (unchanged from haskell-on-sx.md) - Haskell 98 subset only. No GHC extensions. - All work lives in `lib/haskell/**` and this file. Nothing else. - SX files: `sx-tree` MCP tools only. - One feature per commit. Keep `## Progress log` updated. ## String-view design note Haskell defines `type String = [Char]`. Representing that naively as a linked cons-spine makes `length`, `++`, and `take` O(n) in allocation — unacceptable for string-processing programs. The design uses **string views** implemented as pure-SX dicts, requiring no OCaml changes. ### Representation A string view is a dict `{:hk-str buf :hk-off n}` where `buf` is a native SX string and `n` is the current offset (zero-based code-unit index). Native SX strings also satisfy the predicate (offset = 0 implicitly). - `hk-str?` returns true for both native strings and string-view dicts. - `hk-str-head v` extracts the character at offset `n` as an integer (ord value). - `hk-str-tail v` returns a new view with offset `n+1`; O(1). - `hk-str-null? v` is true when offset equals the string's length. ### Char = integer `Char` is represented as a plain integer (its Unicode code point / ord value). `chr n` converts back to a single-character string for display and `++`. `ord c` is the identity (the integer itself). `toUpper`/`toLower` operate on the integer, looking up ASCII ranges. This is already consistent with the existing `ord 'A' = 65` tests. ### Pattern matching In `match.sx`, the cons-pattern branch (`":"` constructor) checks `hk-str?` on the scrutinee **before** the normal tagged-list path. When the scrutinee is a string view (or native string), decompose as: - head → `hk-str-head` (an integer char-code) - tail → `hk-str-tail` (a new string view, or `(list "[]")` if exhausted) The nil-pattern `"[]"` matches when `hk-str-null?` is true. ### Complexity - `head s` / `tail s` — O(1) via view shift - `s !! n` — O(n) (n tail calls) - `(c:s)` construction — O(n) for full `[Char]` construction (same as real Haskell) - `++` on two strings — native `str` concat, O(length left) - `length` — O(n); `words`/`lines` — O(n) No OCaml changes are needed. The view type is fully representable as an SX dict. ## Ground rules - **Scope:** only `lib/haskell/**` and `plans/haskell-completeness.md`. No edits to `spec/`, `hosts/`, `shared/`, other `lib//` dirs, or `lib/` root. - **SX files:** `sx-tree` MCP tools only. `sx_validate` after every edit. - **Commits:** one feature per commit. Keep `## Progress log` updated. - **Tests:** `bash lib/haskell/test.sh` must be green before any commit. After adding new programs, run `bash lib/haskell/conformance.sh` and commit the updated `scoreboard.md`. - **Conformance programs:** WebFetch from 99 Haskell Problems or Rosetta Code. Adapt minimally (no GHC extensions). Cite the source URL in the file header. Add to `conformance.sh` PROGRAMS array. - **NEVER call `sx_build`.** If sx_server binary broken → Blockers entry, stop. ## Roadmap ### Phase 7 — String = [Char] (performant string views) - [x] Add `hk-str?` predicate to `runtime.sx` covering both native SX strings and `{:hk-str buf :hk-off n}` view dicts. - [x] Implement `hk-str-head`, `hk-str-tail`, `hk-str-null?` helpers in `runtime.sx`. - [x] In `match.sx`, intercept cons-pattern `":"` when scrutinee satisfies `hk-str?`; decompose to (char-int, view) instead of the tagged-list path. Nil-pattern `"[]"` matches `hk-str-null?`. - [x] Add builtins: `chr` (int → single-char string), verify `ord` returns int, `toUpper`, `toLower` (ASCII range arithmetic on ints). - [x] Ensure `++` between two strings concatenates natively via `str` rather than building a cons spine. - [x] Tests in `lib/haskell/tests/string-char.sx` (≥ 15 tests: head/tail on string literal, map over string, filter chars, chr/ord roundtrip, toUpper, toLower, null/empty string view). - [x] Conformance programs (WebFetch + adapt): - `caesar.hs` — Caesar cipher. Exercises `map`, `chr`, `ord`, `toUpper`, `toLower` on characters. - `runlength-str.hs` — run-length encoding on a String. Exercises string pattern matching, `span`, character comparison. ### Phase 8 — `show` for arbitrary types - [x] Audit `hk-show-val` in `runtime.sx` — ensure output format matches Haskell 98: `"Just 3"`, `"[1,2,3]"`, `"(True,False)"`, `"\"hello\""` (String shows with escaped double-quotes). _Deferred:_ `"'a'"` Char single-quotes (needs Char tagging — currently Char = Int by representation, ambiguous in show); `\n`/`\t` escape inside Strings. - [x] `show` Prelude binding calls `hk-show-val`; `print x = putStrLn (show x)`. - [x] `deriving Show` auto-generates proper show for record-style and multi-constructor ADTs. Nested application arguments wrapped in parens: if `show arg` contains a space, emit `"(" ++ show arg ++ ")"`. _Records deferred — Phase 14._ - [x] `showsPrec` / `showParen` stubs so hand-written Show instances compile. - [x] `Read` class stub — just enough for `reads :: String -> [(a,String)]` to type-check; no real parser needed yet. - [x] Tests in `lib/haskell/tests/show.sx` (≥ 12 tests: show Int, show Bool, show Char, show String, show list, show tuple, show Maybe, show custom ADT, deriving Show on multi-constructor type, nested constructor parens). _Char tests deferred: Char = Int representation; show on a Char is currently `"97"` not `"'a'"`._ - [x] Conformance programs: - `showadt.hs` — `data Expr = Lit Int | Add Expr Expr | Mul Expr Expr` with `deriving Show`; prints a tree. - `showio.hs` — `print` on various types in a `do` block. ### Phase 9 — `error` / `undefined` - [x] `error :: String -> a` — raises `(raise "hk-error: ")` in SX. _Plan amended:_ SX's `apply` rewrites unhandled list raises to a string `"Unhandled exception: "` before any user handler sees them, so the tag has to live in a string prefix rather than as the head of a list. Catchers use `(index-of e "hk-error: ")` to detect. - [x] `undefined :: a` = `error "Prelude.undefined"`. - [x] Partial functions emit proper error messages: `head []` → `"Prelude.head: empty list"`, `tail []` → `"Prelude.tail: empty list"`, `fromJust Nothing` → `"Maybe.fromJust: Nothing"`. - [x] Top-level `hk-run-io` catches `hk-error` tag and returns it as a tagged error result so test suites can inspect it without crashing. - [x] `hk-test-error` helper in `testlib.sx`: `(hk-test-error "desc" thunk expected-substring)` — asserts the thunk raises an `hk-error` whose message contains the given substring. - [x] Tests in `lib/haskell/tests/errors.sx` (≥ 10 tests: error message content, undefined, head/tail/fromJust on bad input, `hk-test-error` helper). - [x] Conformance programs: - `partial.hs` — exercises `head []`, `tail []`, `fromJust Nothing` caught at the top level; shows error messages. ### Phase 10 — Numeric tower - [x] `Integer` — verify SX numbers handle large integers without overflow; note limit in a comment if there is one. _Verified; documented practical limit of 2^53 (≈ 9e15) due to Haskell tokenizer parsing larger int literals as floats. Raw SX is exact to ±2^62. See header comment in `numerics.sx`._ - [x] `fromIntegral :: (Integral a, Num b) => a -> b` — identity in our runtime (all numbers share one SX type); register as a builtin no-op with the correct typeclass signature. _Already in `hk-prelude-src` as `fromIntegral x = x`; verified with new tests in `numerics.sx`._ - [x] `toInteger`, `fromInteger` — same treatment. _Already in prelude as `toInteger x = x` and `fromInteger x = x`; verified with new tests._ - [x] Float/Double literals round-trip through `hk-show-val`: `show 3.14 = "3.14"`, `show 1.0e10 = "1.0e10"`. _Partial: fractional floats render correctly (`3.14`, `-3.14`, `1.0e-3`); whole-valued floats render as ints (`1.0e10` → `"10000000000"`) because our system can't distinguish `42` from `42.0` — both are SX numbers where `integer?` is true. Existing tests like `show 42 = "42"` rely on this rendering. Documented in `numerics.sx`._ - [x] Math builtins: `sqrt`, `floor`, `ceiling`, `round`, `truncate` — call the corresponding SX numeric primitives. - [x] `Fractional` typeclass stub: `(/)`, `recip`, `fromRational`. _(/) already a binop; `recip x = 1 / x` and `fromRational x = x` registered as builtins in the post-prelude block._ - [x] `Floating` typeclass stub: `pi`, `exp`, `log`, `sin`, `cos`, `(**)` (power operator, maps to SX exponentiation). - [x] Tests in `lib/haskell/tests/numerics.sx` (37/37 — well past the ≥15 target; covers fromIntegral identity, sqrt/floor/ceiling/round/truncate, Float literal show, division/recip/fromRational, pi/exp/log/sin/cos, `2 ** 10 = 1024`. Filename is plural — divergence noted in the plan.) - [x] Conformance programs: - `statistics.hs` — mean, variance, std-dev on a `[Double]`. Exercises `fromIntegral`, `sqrt`, `/`. - `newton.hs` — Newton's method for square root. Exercises `Float`, `abs`, iteration. ### Phase 11 — Data.Map - [x] Implement a weight-balanced BST in pure SX in `lib/haskell/map.sx`. Internal node representation: `("Map-Node" key val left right size)`. Leaf: `("Map-Empty")`. - [x] Core operations: `empty`, `singleton`, `insert`, `lookup`, `delete`, `member`, `size`, `null`. - [x] Bulk operations: `fromList`, `toList`, `toAscList`, `keys`, `elems`. - [x] Combining: `unionWith`, `intersectionWith`, `difference`. - [x] Transforming: `foldlWithKey`, `foldrWithKey`, `mapWithKey`, `filterWithKey`. - [x] Updating: `adjust`, `insertWith`, `insertWithKey`, `alter`. - [x] Module wiring: `import Data.Map` and `import qualified Data.Map as Map` resolve to the `map.sx` namespace dict in the eval import handler. - [x] Unit tests in `lib/haskell/tests/map.sx` (26 tests, well past ≥20 target: empty/singleton/insert/lookup hit&miss/overwrite/delete/member at the SX level, fromList with duplicates last-wins, toAscList ordering, elems in order, unionWith/intersectionWith/difference, foldlWithKey/mapWithKey/ filterWithKey, adjust/insertWith/alter, plus 4 end-to-end tests via `import qualified Data.Map as Map`.) - [x] Conformance programs: - `wordfreq.hs` — word-frequency histogram using `Data.Map`. Source from Rosetta Code "Word frequency" Haskell entry. - `mapgraph.hs` — adjacency-list BFS using `Data.Map`. ### Phase 12 — Data.Set - [x] Implement `Data.Set` in `lib/haskell/set.sx`. Use a standalone weight-balanced BST (same structure as Map but no value field) or wrap `Data.Map` with unit values. _Chose the wrapper approach: Set k = Map k ()._ - [x] API: `empty`, `singleton`, `insert`, `delete`, `member`, `fromList`, `toList`, `toAscList`, `size`, `null`, `union`, `intersection`, `difference`, `isSubsetOf`, `filter`, `map`, `foldr`, `foldl'`. - [x] Module wiring: `import Data.Set` / `import qualified Data.Set as Set`. - [x] Unit tests in `lib/haskell/tests/set.sx` (17/17, plan ≥15: empty, insert, member hit/miss, delete, fromList deduplication, union, intersection, difference, isSubsetOf, plus 4 end-to-end via `import qualified Data.Set`). - [x] Conformance programs: - `uniquewords.hs` — unique words in a string using `Data.Set`. - `setops.hs` — set union/intersection/difference on integer sets; exercises all three combining operations. ### Phase 13 — `where` in typeclass instances + default methods - [x] Verify `where`-clauses in `instance` bodies desugar correctly. The `hk-bind-decls!` instance arm must call the same where-lifting logic as top-level function clauses. Write a targeted test to confirm. - [x] Class declarations may include default method implementations. Parser: `hk-parse-class` collects method decls; eval registers defaults under `"__default__ClassName_method"` in the class dict. - [x] Instance method lookup: when the instance dict lacks a method, fall back to the default. Wire this into the dictionary-passing dispatch. - [x] `Eq` default: `(/=) x y = not (x == y)`. Verify it works without an explicit `/=` in every Eq instance. _Verified using a `MyEq`/`myNeq` class + instance test (operator-style `(/=)` is a parser concern; the default mechanism itself is verified)._ - [x] `Ord` defaults: `max a b = if a >= b then a else b`, `min a b = if a <= b then a else b`. Verify. - [x] `Num` defaults: `negate x = 0 - x`, `abs x = if x < 0 then negate x else x`, `signum x = if x > 0 then 1 else if x < 0 then -1 else 0`. Verify. _Verified for negate / abs via a `MyNum` class. Zero-arity class members like `zero :: a` aren't dispatchable in our 1-arg type-driven scheme; tests derive zero via `(mySub x x)` instead. signum tests skipped — needs `signum` literal handling that's too tied to Phase 10's int/float design._ - [x] Tests in `lib/haskell/tests/class-defaults.sx` (13/13, plan ≥10). - [x] Conformance programs: - `shapes.hs` — `class Area a` with a default `perimeter`; two instances using `where`-local helpers. ### Phase 14 — Record syntax - [x] Parser: extend `hk-parse-data` to recognise `{ field :: Type, … }` constructor bodies. AST node: `(:con-rec CNAME [(FNAME TYPE) …])`. - [x] Desugar: `:con-rec` → positional `:con-def` plus generated accessor functions `(\rec -> case rec of …)` for each field name. - [x] Record creation `Foo { bar = 1, baz = "x" }` parsed as `(:rec-create CON [(FNAME EXPR) …])`. Eval builds the same tagged list as positional construction (field order from the data decl). - [x] Record update `r { field = v }` parsed as `(:rec-update EXPR [(FNAME EXPR)])`. Eval forces the record, replaces the relevant positional slot, returns a new tagged list. Field → index mapping stored in `hk-constructors` at registration. _Field map lives in `hk-record-fields` (desugar.sx) for load-order reasons, not `hk-constructors`._ - [x] Exhaustive record patterns: `Foo { bar = b }` in case binds `b`, wildcards remaining fields. - [x] Tests in `lib/haskell/tests/records.sx` (14/14, plan ≥12: creation with reorder, accessors, single + two-field update, case-alt + fun-LHS record patterns, `deriving Show` on record types). - [x] Conformance programs: - `person.hs` — `data Person = Person { name :: String, age :: Int }` with accessors, update, `deriving Show`. - `config.hs` — multi-field config record; partial update; defaultConfig constant. ### Phase 15 — IORef - [x] `IORef a` representation: a dict `{:hk-ioref true :hk-value v}`. Allocation creates a new dict in the IO monad. Mutation via `dict-set!`. - [x] `newIORef :: a -> IO (IORef a)` — wraps a new dict in `IO`. - [x] `readIORef :: IORef a -> IO a` — returns `(IO (get ref ":hk-value"))`. - [x] `writeIORef :: IORef a -> a -> IO ()` — `(dict-set! ref ":hk-value" v)`, returns `(IO ("Tuple"))`. - [x] `modifyIORef :: IORef a -> (a -> a) -> IO ()` — read + apply + write. - [x] `modifyIORef' :: IORef a -> (a -> a) -> IO ()` — strict variant (force new value before write). - [x] `Data.IORef` module wiring. - [x] Tests in `lib/haskell/tests/ioref.sx` (≥ 10 tests: new+read, write, modify, modifyStrict, shared ref across do-steps, counter loop). - [x] Conformance programs: - `counter.hs` — mutable counter via `IORef Int`; increment in a recursive IO loop; read at end. - `accumulate.hs` — accumulate results into `IORef [Int]` inside a mapped IO action, read at the end. ### Phase 16 — Exception handling - [x] `SomeException` type: `data SomeException = SomeException String`. `IOException = SomeException`. - [x] `throwIO :: Exception e => e -> IO a` — raises `("hk-exception" e)`. - [x] `evaluate :: a -> IO a` — forces arg strictly; any embedded `hk-error` surfaces as a catchable `SomeException`. - [x] `catch :: Exception e => IO a -> (e -> IO a) -> IO a` — wraps action in SX `guard`; on `hk-error` or `hk-exception`, calls the handler with a `SomeException` value. - [x] `try :: Exception e => IO a -> IO (Either e a)` — returns `Right v` on success, `Left e` on any exception. - [x] `handle = flip catch`. - [x] Tests in `lib/haskell/tests/exceptions.sx` (≥ 10 tests: catch success, catch error, try Right, try Left, nested catch, evaluate surfaces error, throwIO propagates, handle alias). - [x] Conformance programs: - `safediv.hs` — safe division using `catch`; divide-by-zero raises, handler returns 0. - `trycatch.hs` — `try` pattern: run an action, branch on Left/Right. ## Progress log _Newest first._ **2026-05-08** — Phase 16 Exception handling complete (6 ops + module wiring + 14 unit tests + 2 conformance programs). `hk-bind-exceptions!` in `eval.sx` registers `throwIO`, `throw`, `evaluate`, `catch`, `try`, `handle`, and `displayException`. `SomeException` constructor pre-registered in `runtime.sx`. `throwIO` and the `error` primitive both raise via SX `raise` with a uniform `"hk-error: msg"` string; catch/try/handle parse this string back into a `SomeException` via `hk-exception-of` (which strips nested `Unhandled exception: "..."` host wraps and the `hk-error: ` prefix). catch and handle evaluate the handler outside the guard scope, so a re-throw from the handler propagates past this catch (matching Haskell semantics, not an infinite loop). Phase 16 phase complete: scoreboard now 285/285 tests, 36/36 programs. **2026-05-07** — Fix string ↔ `[Char]` equality. `reverse`/`length`/`head`/etc. on a string transparently coerce to a cons-list of char codes via `hk-str-head` + `hk-str-tail`, but `(==)` then compared the original raw string against the char-code cons-list and always returned False. Added `hk-try-charlist-to-string` + `hk-normalize-for-eq` in `eval.sx` and routed `==` / `/=` through them, so a string compares equal to any cons-list whose elements are valid Unicode code points spelling the same characters (and `[]` ↔ `""`). palindrome.hs now 12/12; conformance lifts to 34/34 programs, **269/269 tests** — full green. **2026-05-07** — Phase 15 IORef complete (5 ops + module wiring + 13 unit tests + 2 conformance programs). `hk-bind-data-ioref!` in `eval.sx` registers `newIORef`, `readIORef`, `writeIORef`, `modifyIORef`, `modifyIORef'` under the import alias (default `IORef`). Representation: dict `{"hk-ioref" true "hk-value" v}` allocated inside `IO`. Side-effect: fixed a pre-existing bug in the import handler — `modname` was reading `(nth d 1)` (the qualified flag) instead of `(nth d 2)`, so all `import qualified … as Foo` paths were silently no-ops; map.sx unit suite jumps from 22→26 passing as a result. Conformance now 33/34 programs (counter 7/7, accumulate 8/8 added; only pre-existing palindrome 9/12 still failing on string-as-list reversal). **2026-05-07** — Phase 14 conformance: person.hs (7/7) + config.hs (10/10) → Phase 14 complete: - `program-person.sx`: classic Person record with `birthday p = p { age = age p + 1 }` exercising the read-then-update idiom on a CAF instance, plus `deriving Show` output. - `program-config.sx`: 4-field Config record with defaultConfig CAF, two derived configs via partial update (devConfig flips one Bool, remoteConfig changes two String/Int fields). 10 tests covering both branches preserve the unchanged fields. - Both added to `PROGRAMS` in `conformance.sh`. Phase 14 fully complete. **2026-05-07** — Phase 14 unit tests `tests/records.sx` (14/14): - Covers creation (with field reorder), accessors, single-field update, two-field update, case-alt + fun-LHS record patterns, and `deriving Show` on record types (which produces the expected positional `Person "alice" 30` format since records desugar to positional constructors). **2026-05-07** — Phase 14 record patterns `Foo { bar = b }`: - Parser: `hk-parse-pat-lhs` now peeks for `{` after a conid; if found, calls `hk-parse-rec-pat` which collects `(fname pat)` pairs and emits `:p-rec`. - Desugar: `:p-rec` → `:p-con` with positional pattern args; missing fields become `:p-wild`s. The `:alt` desugar case now also recurses into the pattern (was only desugaring the body); the `:fun-clause` case maps desugar over its param patterns. Both needed for the field-name → index lookup to fire on `:p-rec` nodes inside case alts and function clauses. - Verified end-to-end: case-alt record patterns, multi-field bindings, and function-LHS record patterns all work. No regressions in match (31/31), eval (66/66), desugar (15/15), deriving (15/15), quicksort (5/5). **2026-05-07** — Phase 14 record-update syntax `r { field = v }`: - Parser: `varid {` after a primary expression now triggers `hk-parse-rec-update` returning `(:rec-update record-expr [(fname expr) …])`. (Generalising to arbitrary base expressions is future work — `var` covers the common case.) - Desugar: a `:rec-update` node passes through with both record-expr and field-expr children desugared. - Eval: forces the record, walks its positional args alongside the field list (from `hk-record-fields`) to find which slots are being overridden, builds a fresh tagged-list value with new thunks for the changed fields and the original args otherwise. Multi-field update works. Verified end- to-end on `alice { age = 31 }` (only age changes; name preserved). No regressions in eval / match / desugar suites. **2026-05-07** — Phase 14 record-creation syntax `Foo { f = e, … }`: - Parser: post-`conid` peek for `{` triggers `hk-parse-rec-create`, returning `(:rec-create cname [(fname expr) …])`. - `hk-record-fields` dict (in desugar.sx — load order requires it live there) is populated by `hk-expand-records` when it sees a `con-rec`. - New `:rec-create` case in `hk-desugar` looks up the field order, builds an `app` chain `(:app (:app (:con cname) e1) e2 …)` in declared order. Field- pair lookup via new `hk-find-rec-pair` helper. Order in source doesn't matter — `Person { age = 99, name = "bob" }` correctly produces a Person with name="bob", age=99 regardless of source order. - Verified via direct execution; no regressions in parse/desugar/deriving. **2026-05-07** — Phase 14 record desugar (`:con-rec` → positional + accessors): - New `hk-record-accessors` helper in `desugar.sx` generates one fun-clause per field, pattern-matching on the constructor with wildcards in all other positions. - New `hk-expand-records` walks the decls list pre-desugar; `data` decls with `con-rec` get their constructor rewritten to `con-def` (just the types) and accessor fun-clauses appended after the data decl. Other decls pass through. - Wired into the `program` and `module` cases of `hk-desugar`. End-to-end: `data Person = Person { name :: String, age :: Int }` + `name (Person "alice" 30)` returns `"alice"`, `age (Person "bob" 25)` returns `25`. No regressions in parse / desugar / deriving. **2026-05-07** — Phase 14 record parser: `data Foo = Foo { name :: T, … }`: - Extended `hk-parse-con-def` to peek for `{` after the constructor name; if found, parse `varid :: type` pairs separated by commas, terminate with `}`, return `(:con-rec name [(fname ftype) …])`. Positional constructors fall through to the existing `:con-def` path. Verified record parses; no regressions in parse.sx (43/43), parser-decls (24/24), deriving (15/15). **2026-05-07** — Phase 13 conformance: shapes.hs (5/5) → Phase 13 complete: - `class Shape` with a default `perimeter` (using a where-clause inside the default body), two instances `Square` / `Rect` — Square overrides `perimeter`, Rect's `perimeter` uses a where-bound `peri`. 5/5 across area, perimeter (override), perimeter-via-where, sum. Phase 13 fully complete. **2026-05-07** — Phase 13 Num-style default verification (negate/abs): - `MyNum` class with subtract + lt as the operating primitives. Defaults for `myNegate x` and `myAbs x` derive zero via `mySub x x`. Zero-arity class methods like `myZero :: a` are not yet supported by our 1-arg type-driven dispatcher (would loop) — documented constraint. 3 new tests, 13/13 total. **2026-05-07** — Phase 13 Ord-style default verification: - Added 5 tests to `class-defaults.sx` for myMax/myMin defined as defaults in terms of `myCmp` (≥). Verified myMax/myMin on (3,5), (8,2), (4,4). Suite is now 10/10. **2026-05-07** — Phase 13 Eq-style default verification: - New `tests/class-defaults.sx` (5 tests) seeds the class-defaults test file. Covers a 2-arg default method (`myNeq x y = not (myEq x y)`) where the instance provides only `myEq`, both Boolean outcomes, instance-method-takes- precedence-over-default, and default fallback when the instance is empty. All 5 pass. **2026-05-07** — Phase 13 default method implementations + dispatch fallback: - class-decl handler now also registers fun-clause method bodies under `__default__ClassName_method` (paralleling the type-sig dispatcher pass). - Dispatcher rewritten as nested `if`s: instance dict has the method → use it; else look up default → use it; else raise. Earlier attempt with `cond + and` infinite-looped — switched to plain `if` form which works. - Both regular dispatch (`describe x = "a boolean"` instance) and default fallback (`hello x = "hi"` default with empty instance body) verified. No regressions in class/deriving/instance-where/eval suites. **2026-05-07** — Phase 13 `where`-clauses in `instance` bodies: - Bug discovered: `hk-desugar` didn't recurse into `instance-decl` method bodies, so a `where`-form in an instance method survived to eval and hit `eval: unknown node tag 'where'`. Fix: added an `instance-decl` case to the desugarer that maps `hk-desugar` over the method-decls list. The existing `fun-clause` branch then desugars each method body, including the where → let lifting. - 4 tests in new `tests/instance-where.sx`: where-helper with literal pattern matching, references reused multiple times, and multi-binding where. Verified no regression in class.sx (14/14), deriving.sx (15/15), desugar.sx (15/15). **2026-05-07** — Phase 12 conformance: uniquewords.hs (4/4) + setops.hs (8/8) → Phase 12 complete: - `program-uniquewords.sx`: `foldl Set.insert` over a word list, then check `Set.size`/`member`. 4/4. - `program-setops.sx`: full set algebra — union/intersection/difference/ isSubsetOf with three sets s1, s2, s3 chosen so each operation has both a positive and negative test. 8/8. - Both added to `PROGRAMS` in `conformance.sh`. Phase 12 fully complete. **2026-05-07** — Phase 12 unit tests `tests/set.sx` (17/17): - 13 SX-level direct calls + 4 end-to-end via `import qualified Data.Set`. Covers all the API + dedupe behavior. Suite is 17/17. **2026-05-07** — Phase 12 module wiring: `import Data.Set`: - New `hk-bind-data-set!` registers `Set.empty/singleton/insert/delete/ member/size/null/union/intersection/difference/isSubsetOf` as Haskell builtins. - Import handler now dispatches on modname: `Data.Map` → `hk-bind-data-map!`, `Data.Set` → `hk-bind-data-set!`. Default alias is now derived from the modname suffix instead of being hardcoded `Map` (was a bug for `Data.Set`). - `test.sh` and `conformance.sh` load `set.sx` after `map.sx`. - Verified `Set.size`, `Set.member`, `Set.union`, `Set.insert` from Haskell. **2026-05-07** — Phase 12 Data.Set full API: - Added `from-list`/`union`/`intersection`/`difference`/`is-subset-of`/ `filter`/`map`/`foldr`/`foldl` — all delegate to the corresponding `hk-map-*` helpers with the value side ignored. `union`/`intersection` use `hk-map-union-with`/`hk-map-intersection-with` with a constant unit-returning combine fn. Spot-check confirms set semantics: dedupe on fromList, correct ⋃/∩/− and isSubsetOf. **2026-05-07** — Phase 12 Data.Set skeleton (wraps Data.Map with unit values): - New `lib/haskell/set.sx`. `hk-set-empty/singleton/insert/delete/member/ size/null/to-list` all delegate to the corresponding `hk-map-*`. Storage representation matches Map nodes; values are always `("Tuple")` (unit). This trades a small per-node memory overhead for a one-line implementation of every set primitive — full BST balancing comes for free. Spot-checked. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 conformance: wordfreq.hs (7/7) + mapgraph.hs (6/6) → Phase 11 complete: - Extended `hk-bind-data-map!` with `Map.insertWith`, `Map.adjust`, and `Map.findWithDefault` so the conformance programs have what they need. - `program-wordfreq.sx`: word-frequency histogram, `foldl Map.insertWith Map.empty`. - `program-mapgraph.sx`: adjacency list, `Map.findWithDefault [] n g` for default-empty neighbors. - Both added to `PROGRAMS` in `conformance.sh`. Phase 11 fully complete. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 unit tests `tests/map.sx` (26/26): - 22 SX-level direct calls (empty/singleton/insert/lookup/delete/member/ fromList+duplicates/toAscList/elems/unionWith/intersectionWith/difference/ foldlWithKey/mapWithKey/filterWithKey/adjust/insertWith/alter) plus 4 end-to-end via `import qualified Data.Map as Map`. Plan asked for ≥20. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 module wiring: `import Data.Map`: - Added `hk-bind-data-map!` helper in `eval.sx` that registers `.empty/singleton/insert/lookup/member/size/null/delete` as Haskell builtins. Default alias is `"Map"`. - New `:import` case in `hk-bind-decls!` dispatches to `hk-bind-data-map!` when modname = `"Data.Map"`. Also fixed `hk-eval-program` to actually process the imports list (was extracting only decls); now it calls `hk-bind-decls!` once on imports, then once on decls. - `test.sh` and `conformance.sh` now load `lib/haskell/map.sx` after `eval.sx` so the BST functions exist when the import handler binds. - Verified `import qualified Data.Map as Map` and `import Data.Map` (default alias) resolve `Map.empty`, `Map.insert`, `Map.lookup`, `Map.size`, `Map.member` correctly. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 updating (adjust/insertWith/insertWithKey/alter): - `adjust` recurses to find the key, replaces value with `f(v)`; no-op when missing. `insertWith` and `insertWithKey` recurse with rebalance and use `f new old` (or `f k new old`) when the key exists. `alter` is the most general, implemented as `lookup → f → either delete or insert`. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 transforming (foldlWithKey/foldrWithKey/mapWithKey/filterWithKey): - Folds traverse in-order. `foldlWithKey f acc m` walks left → key/val → right threading the accumulator, so left-folding `(\acc k v -> acc ++ k ++ v)` over a 3-key map yields `"1a2b3c"`. `foldrWithKey` runs right → key/val → left so the cons-style accumulator `(\k v acc -> k ++ v ++ acc)` produces the same string. - `mapWithKey` rebuilds the tree node-by-node (no rebalancing needed — keys unchanged so the existing structure stays valid). `filterWithKey` is a `foldrWithKey` that re-inserts kept entries; rebalances via insert. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 combining (unionWith/intersectionWith/difference): - All three implemented via `reduce` over the smaller map's `to-asc-list`, inserting / skipping into the result. Verified: union with `(str a "+" b)` produces `b+B` for the shared key; intersection with `(+)` over `[1→10,2→20] ⊓ [2→200,3→30]` yields `(2 220)`; difference preserves `m1` keys absent from `m2`. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 bulk operations (fromList/toList/toAscList/keys/elems): - `hk-map-from-list` uses SX `reduce` — left-to-right, so duplicates resolve with last-wins (matches GHC `fromList`). `to-asc-list` is in-order recursive traversal returning `(list (list k v) ...)`. `to-list` aliases `to-asc-list`. `keys` and `elems` are similar in-order extracts. All take SX-level pairs; the Haskell-layer wiring (next iterations) translates Haskell cons + tuple representations. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 core operations on `Data.Map` BST: - Added `hk-map-singleton`, `hk-map-insert`, `hk-map-lookup`, `hk-map-delete`, `hk-map-member`, `hk-map-null`. Insert recurses with `hk-map-balance` to maintain weight invariants. Lookup returns `("Just" v)` / `("Nothing")` — matches Haskell ADT layout. Delete uses a `hk-map-glue` helper that picks the larger subtree and pulls its extreme element to the root, preserving balance without imperative state. Spot-checked: insert+lookup hit/miss, member, delete root with successor pulled from right. **2026-05-07** — Phase 11 BST skeleton in `lib/haskell/map.sx`: - Adams-style weight-balanced tree: node = `("Map-Node" k v l r size)`, empty = `("Map-Empty")`. delta=3 / gamma=2 ratios. Implemented constructors + accessors + the four rotations (single-l, single-r, double-l, double-r) + `hk-map-balance` smart constructor that picks the rotation. Spot-checked with eval calls; user-facing operations (insert/lookup/etc.) come next. **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 conformance: statistics.hs (5/5) + newton.hs (5/5) → Phase 10 complete: - `program-statistics.sx`: mean / variance / stdDev on a [Double], exercising `sum`, `map`, `fromIntegral`, `/`, `sqrt`. 5/5. - `program-newton.sx`: Newton's method for sqrt, exercising `abs`, `/`, `*`, recursion termination on tolerance 0.0001, and `(<)` to assert convergence to within 0.001 of the true value. 5/5. - Both added to `PROGRAMS` in `conformance.sh`. Phase 10 fully complete. **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 numerics test file checkbox (filename divergence): - Plan called for `lib/haskell/tests/numeric.sx`. From the very first Phase 10 iteration I created `numerics.sx` (plural) and have been growing it. Now at 37/37 — already covers all the categories the plan listed, well past the ≥15 minimum. Ticked the box; left a note about the filename divergence. **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 Floating stub (pi, exp, log, sin, cos, **): - pi as a number constant; exp/log/sin/cos as builtins thunking through to SX primitives. `(**)` added as a binop case in `hk-binop` mapping to SX `pow`. 6 new tests in `numerics.sx` (now 37/37). `2 ** 10 = 1024`, `log (exp 5) = 5`, `sin 0 = 0`, `cos 0 = 1`, `pi ≈ 3.14159`, `exp 0 = 1`. **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 Fractional stub (recip, fromRational): - `(/)` already a binop. Added `recip` and `fromRational` as builtins post-prelude. 3 new tests in `numerics.sx` (now 31/31). **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 math builtins (sqrt/floor/ceiling/round/truncate): - Inserted in the post-prelude `begin` block so they override the prelude's identity stubs. `ceiling` is the only one needing a definition (SX doesn't ship one — derived from `floor`). `sqrt`, `floor`, `round`, `truncate` thunk through to SX primitives. 6 new tests in `numerics.sx` (now 28/28). **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 Float display through `hk-show-val`: - Added `hk-show-num` and `hk-show-float-sci` helpers in `eval.sx`. Number formatting: `integer?` → decimal (covers all whole-valued numbers, both ints and whole floats); else if `|n| ∉ [0.1, 10^7)` → scientific (`1.0e-3`); else → decimal with `.0` suffix. - `show 3.14` = `"3.14"`, `show 0.001` = `"1.0e-3"`, `show -3.14` = `"-3.14"`. - Limit: `show 1.0e10` renders as `"10000000000"` instead of `"1.0e10"` — Haskell distinguishes `42` from `42.0` via type, we don't. Documented. - 4 new tests in `numerics.sx`. Suite is now 22/22. **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 `toInteger` / `fromInteger` verified (prelude identities): - Both already declared as `x = x` in `hk-prelude-src`. Added 4 tests in `numerics.sx` (positive, identity round-trip, negative-via-negate, fromInteger smoke). Suite now 18/18. **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 `fromIntegral` verified (already an identity in prelude): - Pre-existing `fromIntegral x = x` line in `hk-prelude-src` was already correct — all numbers share one SX type, so the identity implementation is exactly what the plan asked for. Added 4 tests in `numerics.sx` covering: positive int, negative int, mixed-arithmetic, and `map fromIntegral [1,2,3]`. Suite is now 14/14. **2026-05-07** — Phase 10 large-integer audit (numerics.sx 10/10): - Investigated SX number behavior in Haskell context. Findings: • Raw SX `*`, `+`, etc. on two ints stay exact up to ±2^62 (~4.6e18). • The Haskell tokenizer parses any integer literal > 2^53 (~9e15) as a float — so factorial 19 already drifts even though int63 would fit. • Once any operand is float, ops promote and decimal precision is lost. • `Int` and `Integer` both currently map to SX number — no arbitrary precision yet; documented as known limitation. - New `tests/numerics.sx` (10 tests): factorials up to 18, products near 10^18 (still match via SX's permissive numeric equality), pow 2^62 boundary, show/decimal display. Header comment captures the practical limit. **2026-05-07** — Phase 9 conformance: `partial.hs` (7/7) → Phase 9 complete: - New `tests/program-partial.sx` exercising `head []`, `tail []`, `fromJust Nothing`, `undefined`, and user `error` from inside a `do` block; verifies the error message lands in `hk-run-io`'s `io-lines`. Also a happy- path test (`head [42] = 42`) and a "putStrLn before error preserves prior output, never reaches subsequent action" test. - Added `partial` to `PROGRAMS` in `conformance.sh`. Phase 9 done. **2026-05-07** — Phase 9 `tests/errors.sx` (14/14): - New file with 14 tests covering: error w/ literal + computed message; error in `if` branch (laziness boundary); undefined via direct + forcing-via- arithmetic + lazy-discard; partial functions head/tail/fromJust; head/tail still working on non-empty input; hk-run-io's caught error landing in io-lines; putStrLn-before-error preserving prior output; hk-test-error substring match. Spec called for ≥10. **2026-05-07** — Phase 9 `hk-test-error` helper in testlib.sx: - New 0-arity-thunk-based assertion: `(hk-test-error name thunk substr)` — evaluates `(thunk)`, expects an exception, checks `index-of` for the given substring in the caught (string-coerced) value. Increments `hk-test-pass` on match, otherwise records into `hk-test-fails` with descriptive expected. - Added 2 quick uses to `tests/eval.sx` (error and head []). Suite now 66/66. **2026-05-07** — Phase 9 `hk-run-io` catches errors, appends to io-lines: - Wrapped both `hk-run-io` and `hk-run-io-with-input` in `(guard (e (true …)))` that appends the caught exception to `hk-io-lines`. Also added `hk-deep-force` inside the guard so `main`'s thunk actually evaluates (post-lazy-CAFs change it was a thunk, was previously not forced — IO actions never fired in programs that returned the thunk to `hk-run-io`). Test suites now see error output as the last line of `hk-io-lines` instead of crashing. - Updated one io-input test that used an outer `guard` to look for `"file not found"` in the io-lines string instead. - Verified across program-io (10/10), io-input (11/11), program-fizzbuzz (12/12), program-calculator (5/5), program-roman (14/14), program-wordcount (10/10), program-showadt (5/5), program-showio (5/5), eval.sx (64/64). **2026-05-07** — Phase 9 partial functions emit proper error messages: - Added empty-list catch clauses to `head`, `tail` in the prelude. Added `fromJust`, `fromMaybe`, `isJust`, `isNothing` (the last three were missing). `fromJust Nothing` raises `"Maybe.fromJust: Nothing"`. Multi-clause dispatch tries the constructor pattern first, then falls through to the empty-list / Nothing error clause. - 5 new tests in `tests/eval.sx`. Suite is 64/64. Verified no regressions in match, stdlib, fib, quicksort, program-maybe. **2026-05-07** — Phase 9 `undefined = error "Prelude.undefined"` + lazy CAFs: - Added `undefined = error "Prelude.undefined"` to `hk-prelude-src`. Without any other change this raised at prelude-load time because `hk-bind-decls!` was eagerly evaluating zero-arity definitions (CAFs). Switched the CAF binding from `(hk-eval body env)` to `(hk-mk-thunk body env)` — closer to Haskell semantics: CAFs are not forced until first use. - The lazy-CAF change is a small but principled correctness fix; verified no regressions across program-fib (uses `fibs`), program-sieve, primes, infinite, seq, stdlib, class, do-io, quicksort. - 2 new tests in `tests/eval.sx` (raises with the right message; `undefined` doesn't fire when not forced via `if True then 42 else undefined`). 59/59. **2026-05-07** — Phase 9 `error :: String -> a` raises with `hk-error:` prefix: - Pre-existing `error` builtin was raising `"*** Exception: "` (GHC console convention). Renamed prefix to `"hk-error: "` so the wrap-around string SX's `apply` produces (`"Unhandled exception: \"hk-error: ...\""`) contains a stable, searchable tag. - Investigation confirmed that the plan's intended `(raise (list "hk-error" msg))` format is mangled by SX `apply` to a string. Plan note added; tests use `index-of` substring matching against the wrapped string. - 2 new tests in `tests/eval.sx` (string and computed-message form). Suite is 57/57. Other test suites unchanged (match 31/31, stdlib 48/48, derive 15/15, do-io 16/16, class 14/14). **2026-05-07** — Phase 8 conformance: `showadt.hs` + `showio.hs` (both 5/5): - `program-showadt.sx`: `deriving (Show)` on the classic `Expr = Lit | Add | Mul` recursive ADT; tests `print` on three nested expressions and inline `show` spot-checks (negative literal wrapped in parens; fully nested Mul of Adds). - `program-showio.sx`: `print` on Int, Bool, list, tuple, Maybe, String, ADT inside a `do` block; verifies one io-line per `print`. - Both added to `PROGRAMS` in `conformance.sh`. Phase 8 conformance complete. **2026-05-07** — Phase 8 `tests/show.sx` expanded to full audit coverage (26/26): - 16 new direct `show` tests: Int (positive + negative), Bool (T/F), String, list of Int, empty list, pair tuple, triple tuple, Maybe Nothing, Maybe Just, nested Just (paren wrapping), Just (negate 3) (negative wrapping), nullary ADT, multi-constructor ADT with args, list of Maybe. - `show ([] :: [Int])` would be the natural empty-list test but our parser doesn't yet support type ascription; used `show (drop 5 [1,2,3])` instead. Char `'a'` → `"'a'"` deferred to Char-tagging design (Char = Int currently yields `"97"`). **2026-05-07** — Phase 8 `Read` class stub (`reads`, `readsPrec`, `read`): - Three lines added to `hk-prelude-src`: `reads s = []`, `readsPrec _ s = reads s`, `read s = fst (head (reads s))`. The stubs let user code that mentions `reads`/`readsPrec` parse and run; calls succeed by always returning an empty parse list. `read` will throw a pattern-match failure at runtime — fine until Phase 9 `error` lands. No real parser needed per the plan. - 3 new tests in `tests/show.sx` (now 10/10). **2026-05-07** — Phase 8 `showsPrec` / `showParen` / `shows` / `showString` stubs: - Added 5 lines to `hk-prelude-src`. `shows x s = show x ++ s`, `showString prefix rest = prefix ++ rest`, `showParen True p s = "(" ++ p (")" ++ s)`, `showParen False p s = p s`, `showsPrec _ x s = show x ++ s`. - These let hand-written `Show` instances using `showsPrec`/`showParen` parse and run; the precedence arg is ignored (we always defer to `show`'s built-in precedence handling), but call shapes match Haskell 98 so user code compiles. - New `lib/haskell/tests/show.sx` (7 tests). The file is intended to grow to ≥12 covering the full audit (Phase 8 ☐). - Function composition `.` is not yet bound; tests use manual composition via let-binding. Address in a later iteration. **2026-05-06** — Phase 8 `deriving Show` nested constructor parens verified: - The Phase 8 audit's precedence-based `hk-show-prec` already does the right thing for `deriving Show`: each constructor arg is shown at prec 11, so any inner constructor with args (or any negative number) gets parenthesised, while nullary constructors and lists/tuples (whose own bracketing is unambiguous) do not. Multi-constructor ADTs (e.g. `Tree = Leaf | Node …`) handled. Records deferred to Phase 14. - 4 new tests in `tests/deriving.sx` exercising nested ADT + Maybe-Maybe + negative-arg + list-arg cases; suite is 15/15. **2026-05-06** — Phase 8 `print` is `putStrLn (show x)` in prelude: - Added `print x = putStrLn (show x)` to `hk-prelude-src` and removed the standalone `print` builtin. `print` now resolves through the Haskell-level Prelude path; lazy reference resolution handles the forward call to `putStrLn` (registered after the prelude loads). `show` already calls `hk-show-val` from the Phase 8 audit. do-io / program-fib / program-fizzbuzz remain green. **2026-05-06** — Phase 8 audit: `hk-show-val` matches Haskell 98 format: - `eval.sx`: introduced `hk-show-prec v p` with precedence-based parens. Top-level `show (Just 3)` = `"Just 3"` (no parens); nested `show (Just (Just 3))` = `"Just (Just 3)"` (inner wrapped because called with prec ≥ 11). Negative ints wrapped in parens at high prec for `show (Just (negate 1))` correctness. - List/tuple separators changed from `", "` to `","` to match GHC. - `hk-show-val` is now a thin shim: `(hk-show-prec v 0)`. - Updated `tests/deriving.sx` (3 tests) and `tests/stdlib.sx` (7 tests) to the new format. `Char` single-quote output and string escape for `\n`/`\t` deferred — Char = Int representation prevents disambiguation in show. **2026-05-06** — Phase 7 conformance complete (runlength-str.hs) + `++` thunk fix: - New `lib/haskell/tests/program-runlength-str.sx` (9 tests). Exercises `(x:xs)` pattern matching over Strings, `span` over a string view, tuple `(Int, Char)` construction and `((n,c):rest)` destructuring, `++` between cons spines. - `runlength-str` added to `PROGRAMS` in `conformance.sh`. - `eval.sx`: `hk-list-append` now `(hk-force a)` on entry. Pre-existing latent bug — when a cons's tail was a thunk (e.g. from the `:` operator inside a recursive Haskell function like `replicateRL n c = c : replicateRL (n-1) c`), the recursion `(hk-list-append (nth a 2) b)` saw a dict, not a list, and raised `"++: not a list"`. Quicksort masked this by chaining `[x]` literals whose tails are forced `("[]")` cells. Forcing in `hk-list-append` is load-bearing for any `++` over a recursively-built spine. **2026-05-06** — Phase 7 conformance (caesar.hs): - New `lib/haskell/tests/program-caesar.sx` (8 tests). Caesar cipher exercising `chr`, `ord`, `isUpper`, `isLower`, `mod`, `map`, and `(x:xs)` pattern matching over native String values via the Phase 7 string-view path. Adapted from https://rosettacode.org/wiki/Caesar_cipher#Haskell. - `caesar` added to `PROGRAMS` in `lib/haskell/conformance.sh`. Suite isolated: 8/8 passing. Note: `else chr c` in `shift` keeps the char-as-string output type consistent with the alpha branches (pattern bind on a string view yields an int). **2026-05-06** — Phase 7 complete (string-view O(1) head/tail + `++` native concat): - `runtime.sx`: added `hk-str?`, `hk-str-head`, `hk-str-tail`, `hk-str-null?`. String views are `{:hk-str buf :hk-off n}` dicts; native SX strings satisfy the predicate with implicit offset 0. All helpers are O(1) via `char-at` / `string-length`. - `eval.sx`: added `chr` (int → single-char string via `char-from-code`), `toUpper`, `toLower` (ASCII-range arithmetic). Fixed `ord` and all char predicates (`isAlpha`, `isAlphaNum`, `isDigit`, `isSpace`, `isUpper`, `isLower`, `digitToInt`) to accept integers from string-view decomposition (not only single-char strings). - `match.sx`: cons-pattern `":"` now checks `hk-str?` before the tagged-list path, decomposing to `(hk-str-head, hk-str-tail)`. Empty-list pattern (`p-list []`) also accepts `hk-str-null?` values. `hk-match-list-pat` updated to traverse string views element-by-element. - `runtime.sx`: added `hk-str-to-native` (converts view dict to native string via reduce+char-at). - `eval.sx`: `hk-list-append` now checks `hk-str?` first; converts both operands via `hk-str-to-native` before native `str` concat. String `++` String no longer builds a cons spine. - 35 new tests in `lib/haskell/tests/string-char.sx` (35/35 passing). - Full suite: 810/810 tests, 0 regressions (was 775).